Warranty woes — a trap and mixed bag game!

September 27, 2025

You’re at Best Buy or wherever. You’re buying that brand-new TV, laptop, or maybe even a sleek espresso machine because, hey, you’re leveling up your life. The cashier drops the question: “Would you like to add the extended warranty?” And boom — you freeze. Is it worth it? Or is it a straight-up scam?

Listen, I’ve been in this boat more times than I can count. And over the years — whether it’s electronics, cars, clothes, or even grooming tools — I’ve seen both sides of the warranty coin. Some warranties are solid. Others? Total garbage. So today, let’s break this down — practical, no fluff, and focused on what’s actually worth your money.

What would you do?

My friend was in another state, driving home, when his tire blew out on the interstate. It was Friday at the end of the business day. He has a 5-year tire & wheel warranty with Toyota, so he searched out the nearest Toyota dealership (a spare tire can only be driven on for a maximum of 50 miles). He arrives at the Toyota and discovers that they don’t have the tire he needs. He must have matching tires for his AWD vehicle (if not, trouble with the drive train components can result). Because the dealership didn’t have the tire he needed, he was told he’d need to replace all the tires. If he gets the tire from a different business, he voids the warranty (plus he’s risking not getting his car operational at the end of Friday business if other places don’t have a match either). To stay within the warranty, he’ll have to get all four tires, which the warranty will cover one (and he’ll keep his warranty for future incidents). So, what would you do?

Will you use or never use — that is the question

THE FALSE SENSE OF SECURITY. Warranties sell peace of mind — that’s the business model. It’s like, “Hey, pay a little extra now so that if anything happens, you’re covered.” But the reality? Most warranties are betting you’ll forget you even bought them. And the kicker — most people NEVER use them. Ever. It’s like buying an insurance policy for your toaster. Bruh, if your toaster breaks, just buy a new one. It’s cheaper than the $40 you just threw at that extended plan.

WHEN WARRANTIES WORK. But I’m not gonna sit here and say warranties are always useless. Let’s be fair. If you’re dropping serious cash — like a $2,000 laptop, a $3,500 fridge, or especially a car — you might want that extra protection. My boy Jay bought a high-end Sony TV with an extended warranty, and sure enough, 11 months later — BOOM — the screen crapped out. He got a full replacement because of that plan. That’s a win.

Traps and games!

BUT HERE’S THE TRAP. The trap is in the fine print. Warranties love to hide behind vague language and exclusions. You think you’re covered, but then — surprise! — “Oh, sorry, this doesn’t apply to accidental damage.” Or, “This only applies if the failure was due to a manufacturer defect.” Like, what the hell does that even mean? If it breaks, it breaks, right?

I’ve seen this nonsense with phone warranties more than I can count. You pay $15/month for a year — that’s $180 — then when the screen cracks? They say it’s not covered, or there’s a $150 deductible. What did you even pay FOR?

CLOTHING & SHOE WARRANTIES? NOPE! Don’t get me started on clothing warranties. Some brands offer “lifetime guarantees” — which sounds badass — until you try to use it. I had a pair of boots that fell apart after like 18 months. The company said, “Oh, that’s due to normal wear and tear.” Dude, what else am I supposed to do with boots? Mount them on my wall?

Unless it’s a high-end brand with a true customer satisfaction guarantee — and I mean one with receipts like Patagonia or Nordstrom — most fashion or grooming products aren’t worth warrantying. Just buy quality up front and take care of your stuff.

THE CAR WARRANTY GAME. Now, let’s talk cars. This is the biggest area where warranties come into play — and the most confusing. Manufacturer warranties? Yes, those are generally solid. But the extended warranties they sell you at the dealership? Mixed bag. I’ve had friends get them and never use ’em. Others saved thousands because of a busted transmission or a faulty A/C unit.

Here’s my take — if the car has a rep for reliability (think Honda, Toyota), skip the extended warranty. If it’s a luxury car with expensive repairs (like BMW or Audi)? Might be smart to get that coverage. Just read the fine print and ask questions before signing anything.

SUBSCRIPTION WARRANTIES– SERIOUSLY?? You know what drives me nuts? These new subscription-style warranties. Like, “Pay $5/month and your blender is covered.” It’s death by a thousand cuts, man. You end up paying way more over time than the item’s even worth. If the blender breaks, toss it. Don’t lock yourself into another monthly payment. We’ve got enough of those already.

USE A CREDIT CARD INSTEAD. Here’s a trick most guys don’t know — some credit cards already give you extended warranty protection for free. That’s right. American Express, Chase Sapphire, and a bunch of others offer an extra year on top of the manufacturer’s warranty just for using their card. So you could skip the store’s upsell completely and still be covered. Smart money move, gents.

BOTTOM LINE IS TO BE STRATEGIC — NOT SCARED. At the end of the day, buying a warranty is a risk trade-off. If the product is cheap or known for reliability — skip it. Don’t waste your cash. If it’s expensive, mission-critical, or prone to problems? Yeah, maybe protect yourself. But never buy a warranty out of fear. Buy it because the math works out.

Your money should work for you — not against you. That’s what this all comes down to. Whether it’s style, grooming, tech, or cars — don’t get played by slick marketing and fine print. Be informed. Be intentional. And remember: peace of mind is great, but overpaying for it is not in the least bit alpha.

Featured video

Effortless style starts with the proper cut. These five low-maintenance hairstyles keep you looking sharp without the constant upkeep, giving you a clean, confident look that fits any occasion!

Pete & Pedro Styling Aids